I’d intended to do a review of each of the seasons of The Witcher independently. However, I recently (last week) finished both seasons, so I should probably just go ahead and talk about them both so as to get them out as I am writing this blog too sporadically to be sure that I’l be able to get my thoughts down on both seasons in separate posts. There’s a lot to like about The Witcher, but there’s also some stuff that I don’t like, so I’ll try to touch on both.
Now, this is coming from someone who has played the video game, but not read the books. I’ve played nearly 300 hours of The Witcher 3 (276 hours), but not yet completed the main quest. I didn’t play games 1 and 2 in the series for one simple reason: CD Projeckt Red chose not to develop/release those games for the Playstation console. While I don’t consider myself an “expert” in The Witcher universe by any means, that 300 hours was more than enough of a “crash course” in “The Witcherverse.”
Season 1
So, right off the bat, the show lives or dies on the strength of the actor portraying Geralt and the character of Geralt. I have to say that Henry Cavill does a great job of embodying the gruff, rough, course witcher that is portrayed in the game. He is very much a younger embodiment of the character (by design), but he really does manage to capture all of the various aspects of Geralt’s character. I think I like this season the best so far, as it sets up some of the conflicts and origins of the characters that were already well established by the time Witcher 3 comes around. I liked Ciri and the actor who portrayed her (I liked all the actors in their various roles, truth be told), and I also liked the “story” of Ciri as well, although since she could only “run,” it did seem a bit much to have her constantly “running away” over the course of the season. My only complaint with Season 1 is the adult content/language. Yes, I know that’s what is in the game (and I would assume the novels), but it just seems so out of place to hear the “F-Bomb” all over the place, for instance.
Season 2
In Season 2, Ciri has much more to do and we get more answers about her past. I think this is both a good and bad thing. It is good that it gives the actor playing Ciri much more to do and the focus isn’t always on Geralt being a “heartless SOB” which is the way they write him whenever he’s not dealing with Ciri. The bad is that there is something “off” with the way they write Geralt once Ciri joins him. It is as if he is trying to be more “compassionate” but this isn’t the way he was written in Season 1. There is a definite shift in tone, specifically when it comes to Geralt. It isn’t the actors, or the even the writing necessarily, but almost a shift in “creative vision” as to how the show should look/work. I didn’t look to see if they changed show runners/producers, but to me, that’s kind of what if feels like–that they changed their conception of the show from the way it presented in the first season. This tonal shift is something that I found jarring and hard to square with my time with the first season. While the language was still present (unfortunately), at least the adult content was toned down this season (no, it’s not gone completely, but it isn’t nearly as “in your face” as in Season 1).
Good, But Not Yet Great
If Netflix does a Season 3, I think that this show could really move into the “great” territory. Right now, I think that the next “season” is a “spin off show” (or something similar), with a (probable) 3rd season rumored to happen/expected to happen based on the release strategy of the previous seasons late in 2023. If it does end up happening, I will more than likely check it out as I’m “invested.” However, I can’t say that I believe that this is the “best” fantasy series I’ve seen as there are both good and bad elements to the show. Still, I find it to be a good show that is better than average and I did enjoy my time watching it.
Sidney
Please consider supporting these fine small press publishers where my work has appeared:
- Read Skin Deep for Free at Aurora Wolf
- Read Childe Roland for Free at Electric Spec
- Purchase HawkeMoon on Amazon.com (Paperback) or eBook
- Purchase Dragonhawk on Amazon.com (Paperback) or Kindle
- Purchase WarLight on Amazon.com (Paperback) or Kindle
- Purchase Ship of Shadows on Amazon.com (Paperback) or Kindle
- Purchase Faerie Knight on Amazon.com (Paperback) or Kindle
Currently Working On (March 2022):
- The Runner (Fantasy Story–4000 words)
2022 Revision; Out to Market. - Unhallowed (Weird Western Story–4100 words)
2022 Revision: Completed; Out to Market. - The Independent (Science Fiction Story–4800 words)
2021 Revision: ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION (Mythic Magazine)